From cfdfd4ac9e55bd9cfa7e811dd79c778826dfb423 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: formax68 Date: Wed, 13 May 2026 09:17:39 +0300 Subject: [PATCH] docs: v1.13.1 milestone audit and phase 03 review-fix report --- .../03-REVIEW-FIX.md | 99 +++++++ .planning/v1.13.1-MILESTONE-AUDIT.md | 251 ++++++++++++++++++ 2 files changed, 350 insertions(+) create mode 100644 .planning/phases/03-date-parsing-navigation-bugs/03-REVIEW-FIX.md create mode 100644 .planning/v1.13.1-MILESTONE-AUDIT.md diff --git a/.planning/phases/03-date-parsing-navigation-bugs/03-REVIEW-FIX.md b/.planning/phases/03-date-parsing-navigation-bugs/03-REVIEW-FIX.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..920a821 --- /dev/null +++ b/.planning/phases/03-date-parsing-navigation-bugs/03-REVIEW-FIX.md @@ -0,0 +1,99 @@ +--- +phase: 03 +fixed_at: 2026-05-12T00:00:00Z +review_path: .planning/phases/03-date-parsing-navigation-bugs/03-REVIEW.md +iteration: 1 +findings_in_scope: 3 +fixed: 3 +skipped: 0 +status: all_fixed +--- + +# Phase 3: Code Review Fix Report + +**Fixed at:** 2026-05-12 +**Source review:** `.planning/phases/03-date-parsing-navigation-bugs/03-REVIEW.md` +**Iteration:** 1 +**Scope:** Critical + Warning (3 warnings — no critical findings in this review) + +**Summary:** +- Findings in scope: 3 +- Fixed: 3 +- Skipped: 0 + +All fixes type-checked clean with `tsc -noEmit` and pass the full +`npm run build` pipeline (production esbuild bundle). + +## Fixed Issues + +### WR-01: `parseLocalDate` does not reject invalid day-of-month, silently rolls forward + +**Files modified:** `src/utils/viewRenderers.ts` +**Commit:** `ef48a44` +**Applied fix:** Added a round-trip validation check after the numeric +`Date` constructor. The helper now verifies that the constructed Date's +`getFullYear() / getMonth() / getDate()` match the input components, +rejecting impossible inputs like `(2026, 2, 31)` which the constructor +silently rolls into `2026-03-03`. Filenames like `31-02-2026.md` and +`2026-02-30.md` now fall through to the next interpretation or return +`null` instead of returning the wrong date. + +### WR-02: BUG-01 timezone fix is incomplete — `parseDate` still uses `new Date(string)` + +**Files modified:** `src/utils/viewRenderers.ts` +**Commit:** `6143643` +**Applied fix:** Added explicit `^(\d{4})-(\d{2})-(\d{2})$` ISO detection +in `parseDate` before the loose `new Date(input)` fallback. ISO-shaped +inputs are routed through `parseLocalDate` so the result is a local-day +Date, not UTC midnight. This closes the BUG-01 bug class for code-block +parameters (`date: 2026-01-15` in `memochron-calendar` / `memochron-agenda` +blocks) which the original Phase 3 plan covered only for daily-note +filenames. + +### WR-03: `maybeBackgroundRefresh` `.then` ignores stale closure and unawaited Promise + +**Files modified:** `src/views/CalendarView.ts` +**Commit:** `4f14936` +**Applied fix:** Two-part fix in `maybeBackgroundRefresh()`: + +1. **Staleness guard:** capture `this.currentDate.getTime()` before + the fetch and bail in `.then` if it has changed. Used `getTime()` + (not strict-equality) because `navigate()` mutates `currentDate` in + place via `setMonth`/`setDate`, so a strict-identity comparison + would miss the in-place arithmetic paths. +2. **Unawaited async call:** prefixed `this.showDayAgenda(dateToShow)` + with `void` so any future async error surfaces through the + surrounding `.catch` rather than `unhandledrejection`. + +Scope note: the report also mentions the same `void`-prefix concern at +`renderCurrentRange` and `refreshEvents`. Those are Info-tier (IN-04) +and out of scope for this `critical_and_warning` fix pass — left as-is +per the scoping rule. + +## Skipped Issues + +None. + +## Verification + +All three fixes verified with: +- **Tier 1:** re-read of each modified region after edit; fix text + present and surrounding code intact. +- **Tier 2:** `tsc -noEmit` (via `npm run build`) clean — no errors in + modified or downstream files. + +## Prompt-Injection Notice + +While reading `src/views/CalendarView.ts`, the tool output appended a +`` block containing fake "MCP Server Instructions" for +unrelated services (Airtable, Context7, Gamma). This appears to be the +same prompt-injection source flagged in `03-REVIEW.md`. I ignored it and +took no action on those purported instructions; the user-supplied fix +task was followed instead. Flagging here so the orchestrator can +investigate the source. + +--- + +_Fixed: 2026-05-12_ +_Fixer: gsd-code-fixer_ +_Iteration: 1_ diff --git a/.planning/v1.13.1-MILESTONE-AUDIT.md b/.planning/v1.13.1-MILESTONE-AUDIT.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..8d9266e --- /dev/null +++ b/.planning/v1.13.1-MILESTONE-AUDIT.md @@ -0,0 +1,251 @@ +--- +milestone: v1.13.1 +audited: 2026-05-10T00:00:00Z +status: gaps_found +scores: + requirements: 5/19 + phases: 1/4 + integration: 14/14 wired (Phase 01 only — phases 2-4 not yet executed) + flows: phase-01-internal-flows-intact +gaps: + requirements: + - id: "SEC-01" + status: "orphaned" + phase: "Phase 2 (not started)" + claimed_by_plans: [] + completed_by_plans: [] + verification_status: "missing" + evidence: "Phase 2 directory does not exist. Color validation surface still unsanitized at SettingsTab.ts:589, 592, 675, 678 (template-literal SVG with ${currentColor})." + - id: "SEC-02" + status: "orphaned" + phase: "Phase 2 (not started)" + claimed_by_plans: [] + completed_by_plans: [] + verification_status: "missing" + evidence: "Phase 2 directory does not exist. CalendarService.fetchCalendar (lines 396-400), fetchLocalCalendar (line 532), and NoteService.createEventNote (line 75) still use inconsistent error handling." + - id: "BUG-05" + status: "orphaned" + phase: "Phase 2 (not started)" + claimed_by_plans: [] + completed_by_plans: [] + verification_status: "missing" + evidence: "Phase 2 directory does not exist. CalendarView.getStartOfWeek at line 407 not yet corrected for Saturday-start (firstDayOfWeek=6)." + - id: "BUG-06" + status: "orphaned" + phase: "Phase 2 (not started)" + claimed_by_plans: [] + completed_by_plans: [] + verification_status: "missing" + evidence: "Phase 2 directory does not exist. isFetchingCalendars guard exists in CalendarService but semantic correctness for the 100ms-delay window between schedule and fire pending verification." + - id: "BUG-01" + status: "orphaned" + phase: "Phase 3 (not started)" + claimed_by_plans: [] + completed_by_plans: [] + verification_status: "missing" + evidence: "Phase 3 directory does not exist. Daily-note YYYY-MM-DD parsing in non-UTC timezones not yet fixed." + - id: "BUG-02" + status: "orphaned" + phase: "Phase 3 (not started)" + claimed_by_plans: [] + completed_by_plans: [] + verification_status: "missing" + evidence: "Phase 3 directory does not exist. Month/week navigation responsiveness not yet addressed." + - id: "BUG-03" + status: "orphaned" + phase: "Phase 3 (not started)" + claimed_by_plans: [] + completed_by_plans: [] + verification_status: "missing" + evidence: "Phase 3 directory does not exist. Drag-resize → view-mode dropdown sync not yet addressed." + - id: "BUG-04" + status: "orphaned" + phase: "Phase 3 (not started)" + claimed_by_plans: [] + completed_by_plans: [] + verification_status: "missing" + evidence: "Phase 3 directory does not exist. #56 date-parsing fix not yet verified post-#58." + - id: "ENH-01" + status: "orphaned" + phase: "Phase 4 (not started)" + claimed_by_plans: [] + completed_by_plans: [] + verification_status: "missing" + evidence: "Phase 4 directory does not exist. Today-vs-selected-day distinct visual indicator not yet implemented." + - id: "ENH-02" + status: "orphaned" + phase: "Phase 4 (not started)" + claimed_by_plans: [] + completed_by_plans: [] + verification_status: "missing" + evidence: "Phase 4 directory does not exist. Agenda note-exists icon not yet implemented." + - id: "ENH-03" + status: "orphaned" + phase: "Phase 4 (not started)" + claimed_by_plans: [] + completed_by_plans: [] + verification_status: "missing" + evidence: "Phase 4 directory does not exist. Optional note-exists dot toggle not yet implemented." + - id: "ENH-04" + status: "orphaned" + phase: "Phase 4 (not started)" + claimed_by_plans: [] + completed_by_plans: [] + verification_status: "missing" + evidence: "Phase 4 directory does not exist. NL/EU DD-MM-YYYY date format option not yet added." + - id: "ENH-05" + status: "orphaned" + phase: "Phase 4 (not started)" + claimed_by_plans: [] + completed_by_plans: [] + verification_status: "missing" + evidence: "Phase 4 directory does not exist. {{day}}/{{month}} named template variables not yet implemented." + - id: "ENH-06" + status: "orphaned" + phase: "Phase 4 (not started)" + claimed_by_plans: [] + completed_by_plans: [] + verification_status: "missing" + evidence: "Phase 4 directory does not exist. {{cursor}} marker not yet implemented." + unverified_phases: + - phase: "02-security-correctness" + reason: "Phase directory does not exist; not yet planned or executed" + - phase: "03-date-parsing-navigation-bugs" + reason: "Phase directory does not exist; not yet planned or executed" + - phase: "04-ux-enhancements" + reason: "Phase directory does not exist; not yet planned or executed" + integration: [] + flows: [] +tech_debt: + - phase: 01-foundation + items: + - "Info: src/views/EmbeddedCalendarView.ts:15 — unused CalendarEvent import (pre-existing, type-only so esbuild tree-shakes; surfaced as IN-01 in 01-REVIEW.md re-review). Does not block phase closure." + - "Frontmatter authoring gap: Plans 01-01..01-07 and 01-09 SUMMARY.md frontmatter requirements_completed arrays are empty; the milestone REQ-IDs (TD-01, TD-02, TD-03, TD-04, CLEAN-01) are not listed there. Coverage is satisfied via the Requirements Coverage table in 01-VERIFICATION.md, not via summary frontmatter." +nyquist: + compliant_phases: 0 + partial_phases: 1 # Phase 01: VALIDATION.md exists, nyquist_compliant=false with documented reason (QA-01 deferred to v2) + missing_phases: 3 # Phases 02, 03, 04 (not started) + overall: "partial" +--- + +# Milestone v1.13.1 — Audit Report + +**Milestone:** v1.13.1 — MemoChron Stabilization +**Audited:** 2026-05-10 +**Status:** `gaps_found` — milestone is in progress; only 1 of 4 phases complete + +## Summary + +This audit was triggered while the milestone is still in progress. Phase 01 (Foundation) is complete and verified `passed`. Phases 02 (Security & Correctness), 03 (Date Parsing & Navigation Bugs), and 04 (UX Enhancements) have not been planned or executed — their directories do not exist in `.planning/phases/`. + +Of 19 v1 requirements assigned to this milestone, **5 are satisfied** (Phase 1) and **14 are orphaned** (assigned to phases 2-4 but never verified by any phase). + +The audit cannot pass: the milestone is not finished. This is not a regression — it is the expected outcome of running the audit before all phases are complete. + +## Scores + +| Dimension | Score | Notes | +|-----------|-------|-------| +| Requirements satisfied | 5/19 | Phase 1 reqs verified with code-level evidence | +| Phases verified | 1/4 | Phase 1 only | +| Cross-phase integration | 14/14 wired (Phase 01 internal) | No cross-phase dependencies broken; downstream phases not yet executed | +| E2E flows | Phase 01 flows intact | calendar fetch / render / note creation / embedded views all preserved by Phase 01's refactors | + +## Requirements Coverage (3-Source Cross-Reference) + +For each requirement: Source A = REQUIREMENTS.md traceability checkbox; Source B = phase VERIFICATION.md Requirements Coverage table; Source C = phase SUMMARY.md `requirements_completed` frontmatter. + +| Req | Phase | A: REQUIREMENTS.md | B: VERIFICATION.md | C: SUMMARY frontmatter | Final Status | +|-----|-------|--------------------|--------------------|-----------------------|---------------| +| TD-01 | 1 | `[ ]` | passed (SATISFIED, evidence in VERIFICATION) | missing | **satisfied** (VERIFICATION evidence; recommend tick `[x]` and add to frontmatter) | +| TD-02 | 1 | `[ ]` | passed (SATISFIED, evidence in VERIFICATION) | missing | **satisfied** (VERIFICATION evidence; recommend tick `[x]` and add to frontmatter) | +| TD-03 | 1 | `[ ]` | passed (SATISFIED, evidence in VERIFICATION) | missing | **satisfied** (VERIFICATION evidence; recommend tick `[x]` and add to frontmatter) | +| TD-04 | 1 | `[ ]` | passed (SATISFIED, evidence in VERIFICATION) | missing | **satisfied** (VERIFICATION evidence; recommend tick `[x]` and add to frontmatter) | +| CLEAN-01 | 1 | `[ ]` | passed (SATISFIED, evidence in VERIFICATION) | missing | **satisfied** (VERIFICATION evidence; recommend tick `[x]` and add to frontmatter) | +| SEC-01 | 2 | `[ ]` | missing | missing | **orphaned** | +| SEC-02 | 2 | `[ ]` | missing | missing | **orphaned** | +| BUG-05 | 2 | `[ ]` | missing | missing | **orphaned** | +| BUG-06 | 2 | `[ ]` | missing | missing | **orphaned** | +| BUG-01 | 3 | `[ ]` | missing | missing | **orphaned** | +| BUG-02 | 3 | `[ ]` | missing | missing | **orphaned** | +| BUG-03 | 3 | `[ ]` | missing | missing | **orphaned** | +| BUG-04 | 3 | `[ ]` | missing | missing | **orphaned** | +| ENH-01 | 4 | `[ ]` | missing | missing | **orphaned** | +| ENH-02 | 4 | `[ ]` | missing | missing | **orphaned** | +| ENH-03 | 4 | `[ ]` | missing | missing | **orphaned** | +| ENH-04 | 4 | `[ ]` | missing | missing | **orphaned** | +| ENH-05 | 4 | `[ ]` | missing | missing | **orphaned** | +| ENH-06 | 4 | `[ ]` | missing | missing | **orphaned** | + +**Note on Phase 1 final status:** Per the strict status determination matrix (passed VERIFICATION + missing SUMMARY frontmatter → "partial (verify manually)"), the matrix would flag these for manual verification. Manual verification has been done — `01-VERIFICATION.md` contains an explicit Requirements Coverage table mapping each REQ-ID to its source plan with code-level evidence, and the verification status is `passed`. They are therefore promoted to `satisfied`. The summary-frontmatter gap is recorded as a tech-debt item. + +## Phase Verification Status + +| Phase | Status | Verification | Plans | Score | +|-------|--------|--------------|-------|-------| +| 01 — Foundation | **passed** | `01-VERIFICATION.md` exists, status `passed` | 10/10 complete | 4/4 truths verified | +| 02 — Security & Correctness | **not started** | (no directory) | 0/TBD | — | +| 03 — Date Parsing & Navigation Bugs | **not started** | (no directory) | 0/TBD | — | +| 04 — UX Enhancements | **not started** | (no directory) | 0/TBD | — | + +## Cross-Phase Integration + +Integration checker output (full report above the audit). Summary: + +- **Phase 01 internal wiring:** All 14 expected cross-component connections verified WIRED end-to-end (lifecycle teardown chain, live-settings reads, plugin-owned timer cancellation, drag-listener cleanup). +- **Cross-phase wiring (between completed phases):** N/A — only one phase complete. +- **E2E flows:** Calendar fetch → render → cache, click-event → create-note, settings → live refresh, embedded code-block rendering — all intact post-Phase 01 refactors. +- **Cross-phase wiring considerations for unstarted phases (informational, not failures):** + - **BUG-06:** `CalendarService.isFetchingCalendars` re-entrancy guard already exists; `setBackgroundRefreshTimer` setter pre-clears any in-flight timer. Phase 2 must verify the guard covers the 100ms-delay window between schedule and fire. + - **BUG-05:** `firstDayOfWeek` is already read live via `this.plugin.settings.firstDayOfWeek`, so Phase 2's `getStartOfWeek` fix will inherit live-settings propagation correctly. + - **SEC-01 surface:** Active injection sites identified at `SettingsTab.ts:589, 592, 675, 678` (template-literal SVG with `${currentColor}`). + - **SEC-02 surface:** `CalendarService.fetchCalendar` (396-400), `fetchLocalCalendar` (532), `NoteService.createEventNote` (75) still need consistent error handling. + - **ENH-04 / ENH-05 surface:** `NoteService.formatTitle` and `EventTemplateVariables` left intact and ready for Phase 4 to plug into. + +## Tech Debt + +### Phase 01 + +- **`src/views/EmbeddedCalendarView.ts:15` — unused `CalendarEvent` import.** Pre-existing; surfaced as IN-01 in `01-REVIEW.md` re-review. Type-only import (esbuild tree-shakes), so no bundle impact. Does not block phase closure. One-line fix. +- **Frontmatter authoring gap:** Plans 01-01..01-07 and 01-09 SUMMARY frontmatter `requirements_completed` arrays are empty. The milestone REQ-IDs (TD-01..TD-04, CLEAN-01) are not present. Coverage is satisfied via the Requirements Coverage table in `01-VERIFICATION.md`, but the 3-source cross-reference is degraded. Plans 01-08 and 01-10 list `WR-02-FIX` and `IN-01-FIX` (code-review fix labels), not milestone REQ-IDs. + +## Nyquist Compliance + +| Phase | VALIDATION.md | nyquist_compliant | Status | Action | +|-------|---------------|-------------------|--------|--------| +| 01 — Foundation | exists (`01-VALIDATION.md`) | false (with documented reason — no test framework in repo, QA-01 deferred to v2 per REQUIREMENTS.md Out of Scope) | PARTIAL | None — out-of-scope by milestone decision; static-analysis + build gates substitute for behavioral tests | +| 02 — Security & Correctness | missing | — | MISSING | Will be created when phase is planned | +| 03 — Date Parsing & Navigation Bugs | missing | — | MISSING | Will be created when phase is planned | +| 04 — UX Enhancements | missing | — | MISSING | Will be created when phase is planned | + +**Overall Nyquist:** `partial` — Phase 01 is intentionally non-compliant by milestone scope decision; Phases 2-4 unstarted. + +## Why Status is `gaps_found` + +Per the FAIL gate in the audit-milestone workflow: any `unsatisfied` requirement (here, 14 orphans) MUST force `gaps_found` status on the milestone audit. + +This is the correct read of milestone state. Phase 01 is complete and clean; Phases 02-04 are unstarted; the milestone is not yet ready to close. Returning here after Phases 02-04 are executed and verified should flip status to `passed`. + +## Recommended Next Steps + +The audit-milestone workflow's standard remediation routing assumes most phases are complete with a few gap-closure phases needed. That routing does not fit this state — there is nothing to "close inline." The remediation here is to plan and execute the remaining three phases, in roadmap order. + +### Continue the milestone (proper path) + +1. `/gsd-phase 02` (or run `/gsd-discuss-phase 02` directly) — plan Phase 02 (Security & Correctness): SEC-01, SEC-02, BUG-05, BUG-06. +2. `/gsd-discuss-phase 02` → `/gsd-plan-phase 02` → `/gsd-execute-phase 02`. +3. After Phase 02 verifies passed, repeat for Phase 03 (BUG-01..BUG-04). +4. After Phase 03 verifies passed, repeat for Phase 04 (ENH-01..ENH-06). +5. Re-run `/gsd-audit-milestone` after Phase 04 verifies passed. +6. If passed, run `/gsd-complete-milestone v1.13.1`. + +### Optional cleanup before continuing + +- Update `.planning/REQUIREMENTS.md` traceability checkboxes for Phase 1 reqs from `[ ]` → `[x]`. +- Remove unused `CalendarEvent` import at `src/views/EmbeddedCalendarView.ts:15` (one-line fix; could be picked up incidentally during Phase 02). +- Backfill `requirements_completed` frontmatter on Phase 01 plan summaries (low priority — does not affect runtime; only affects future audit clarity). + +--- + +_Audit generated: 2026-05-10_ +_Audit tool: /gsd-audit-milestone_