lllin000_PaperForge/audit/27MSS3VH/audit_report.json

517 lines
No EOL
16 KiB
JSON

{
"paper_key": "27MSS3VH",
"mode": "high-risk",
"status": "READY",
"focus": [],
"artifact_fingerprint": {
"result_json_hash": "sha256:d28308199b15dc306796f0a5c68f4f9b36f8411ffc37486c1c0fc9c994208155",
"meta_json_hash": "sha256:7bcf6bb36a5d80834eee07b6e53d5a7a0a6b1ec0466b15503b6a6922cca43b2b",
"blocks_raw_hash": "sha256:f8438964c274440b439941b488a52c0f51afdbfb6bb5757e387cba20acc6aa67",
"structured_blocks_hash": "sha256:d42b5092dba7e6d37cc22acbd197fed4d2a69c046dc2e8bd28c143ffc5dbbab9",
"document_structure_hash": "sha256:fbd59b4d0e70b24de5bf5d89728895203eefddc78695843d49bee1b639321d28",
"figure_inventory_hash": "sha256:336ef2329541f6b8fc11b415a5c544871b0363b036bdb771eac2f8b6d5b437b4",
"table_inventory_hash": "sha256:01a8da0a5b81cc044cffce3758fa08e9cc774d950a4454412b4798bfe97591c4",
"reader_figures_hash": "sha256:4bd8d60fe2d4bebadef4baa811206f566d81c09e9a66ccab5f9b3fb567eaf61f",
"resolved_metadata_hash": "sha256:a8879275087584d1d148e3c7b20b9a88bfbe5c8278f1eaf2ce6516817058d7e6",
"fulltext_hash": "sha256:f0d4a0f221ff70642f15dc5f3167f60cb2a3e57936054b1601fe8fe194d925d3",
"block_trace_hash": "sha256:0a2717591ba259802103c7ff7fd56d8e46725324330e0f3d79d65da0f6f5281f",
"annotated_pages": {
"page_001.png": "sha256:28f7f5539d3388bcd5a8907f350c0b37104624cae251795b1595505f20f979a0",
"page_002.png": "sha256:cc0d454543312f21b3528cec04257914ae50b2377ae9c53fce46ad5329233ac6",
"page_003.png": "sha256:db46b8782cf1aee19ac1ddd710a69e8fa8328b4b77c0d777be6081539e10e279",
"page_004.png": "sha256:400421b630c52f54daab84597c7b826d3b9eccad88c03468e3e5038e3c6a95de",
"page_005.png": "sha256:203d121ec8bc98be9ee7f2ee393de2c9920895f0fd6c5a2eafe9a2f8c84e8139",
"page_006.png": "sha256:051a18b2f7a426a196ecad62a40de70c964773892f3077298b0ce0b53d8e456a",
"page_007.png": "sha256:743827b674468ba8c560a5efcc6decf61b4d3127a077bf9726af47db19017671",
"page_008.png": "sha256:60936efa8565a97a2031315e0b441762b7bec9525490104dbc3f562808c87a6b",
"page_009.png": "sha256:f78784333211776fb01880c06eaf323e94fa42fd9c58f5b2cf5ed0e060fc4f51",
"page_010.png": "sha256:885d0d35a1e3da81956c2d81d82f479ceb3831dede384a3c34f3c4307f60c29d",
"page_011.png": "sha256:9684e430dff2e6c0bb560f817d481c6435de5b28210ce9cf5dca58c2bd8b0877",
"page_012.png": "sha256:3eac6016f50f315bfd7723ba2678d558730589f7bedc6bcf413c2de1ee9a9a04",
"page_013.png": "sha256:1bb3b6ab222325f5ffd9eb0fd13fbd9d25e7a1fb453b64de7db223648cb586a4",
"page_014.png": "sha256:67cb5d6d37d83592618b60a9d77e1a9c62402aa9bc2fc0b416929344ee2c62aa"
}
},
"artifact_freshness": {
"missing": [],
"mismatches": [
"document_structure older than blocks_structured",
"figure_inventory older than blocks_structured",
"table_inventory older than blocks_structured",
"resolved_metadata older than blocks_structured"
],
"annotated_pages_rendered": [
"page_001.png",
"page_002.png",
"page_003.png",
"page_004.png",
"page_005.png",
"page_006.png",
"page_007.png",
"page_008.png",
"page_009.png",
"page_010.png",
"page_011.png",
"page_012.png",
"page_013.png",
"page_014.png"
]
},
"reviewed_pages": [
1,
3,
4,
5,
6,
8,
10,
11
],
"reviewed_blocks": [
"p1:0",
"p1:1",
"p1:2",
"p1:3",
"p1:4",
"p1:5",
"p1:6",
"p1:7",
"p1:8",
"p1:9",
"p1:10",
"p1:11",
"p1:12",
"p1:13",
"p1:14",
"p1:15",
"p1:16",
"p3:0",
"p3:1",
"p3:2",
"p3:3",
"p3:4",
"p3:5",
"p3:6",
"p3:7",
"p3:8",
"p3:9",
"p3:10",
"p3:11",
"p4:0",
"p4:1",
"p4:2",
"p4:3",
"p4:4",
"p4:5",
"p4:6",
"p5:0",
"p5:1",
"p5:2",
"p5:3",
"p5:4",
"p5:5",
"p5:6",
"p5:7",
"p5:8",
"p5:9",
"p6:0",
"p6:1",
"p6:2",
"p6:3",
"p6:4",
"p6:5",
"p6:6",
"p6:7",
"p6:8",
"p6:9",
"p8:0",
"p8:1",
"p8:2",
"p8:3",
"p8:4",
"p8:5",
"p8:6",
"p8:7",
"p8:8",
"p8:9",
"p8:10",
"p8:11",
"p8:12",
"p8:13",
"p10:0",
"p10:1",
"p10:2",
"p10:3",
"p10:4",
"p10:5",
"p10:6",
"p10:7",
"p10:8",
"p10:9",
"p10:10",
"p10:11",
"p11:0",
"p11:1",
"p11:2",
"p11:3",
"p11:4",
"p11:5",
"p11:6",
"p11:7",
"p11:8",
"p11:9",
"p11:10",
"p11:11",
"p11:12",
"p11:13",
"p11:14",
"p11:15",
"p11:16",
"p11:17",
"p11:18",
"p11:19",
"p11:20",
"p11:21",
"p11:22",
"p11:23",
"p11:24",
"p11:25",
"p11:26",
"p11:27",
"p11:28",
"p11:29",
"p11:30",
"p11:31",
"p11:32",
"p11:33",
"p11:34",
"p11:35"
],
"findings": [
{
"category": "reference_span_error",
"severity": "critical",
"block_ids": [
"p11:17"
],
"truth": "block should remain outside the accepted reference span",
"pipeline_behavior": "block appears inside the logical reference reading-order region",
"root_cause_hypothesis": "logical_order_between_reference_members",
"evidence": {
"annotated_page": "annotated_pages/page_011.png",
"artifact": "reference_span_audit.json"
}
},
{
"category": "reference_span_error",
"severity": "critical",
"block_ids": [
"p11:18"
],
"truth": "block should remain outside the accepted reference span",
"pipeline_behavior": "block appears inside the logical reference reading-order region",
"root_cause_hypothesis": "logical_order_between_reference_members",
"evidence": {
"annotated_page": "annotated_pages/page_011.png",
"artifact": "reference_span_audit.json"
}
},
{
"category": "reference_span_error",
"severity": "critical",
"block_ids": [
"p11:19"
],
"truth": "block should remain outside the accepted reference span",
"pipeline_behavior": "block appears inside the logical reference reading-order region",
"root_cause_hypothesis": "logical_order_between_reference_members",
"evidence": {
"annotated_page": "annotated_pages/page_011.png",
"artifact": "reference_span_audit.json"
}
},
{
"category": "reference_span_error",
"severity": "critical",
"block_ids": [
"p11:20"
],
"truth": "block should remain outside the accepted reference span",
"pipeline_behavior": "block appears inside the logical reference reading-order region",
"root_cause_hypothesis": "logical_order_between_reference_members",
"evidence": {
"annotated_page": "annotated_pages/page_011.png",
"artifact": "reference_span_audit.json"
}
},
{
"category": "reference_span_error",
"severity": "critical",
"block_ids": [
"p11:21"
],
"truth": "block should remain outside the accepted reference span",
"pipeline_behavior": "block appears inside the logical reference reading-order region",
"root_cause_hypothesis": "logical_order_between_reference_members",
"evidence": {
"annotated_page": "annotated_pages/page_011.png",
"artifact": "reference_span_audit.json"
}
},
{
"category": "reference_span_error",
"severity": "critical",
"block_ids": [
"p11:22"
],
"truth": "block should remain outside the accepted reference span",
"pipeline_behavior": "block appears inside the logical reference reading-order region",
"root_cause_hypothesis": "logical_order_between_reference_members",
"evidence": {
"annotated_page": "annotated_pages/page_011.png",
"artifact": "reference_span_audit.json"
}
},
{
"category": "reference_span_error",
"severity": "critical",
"block_ids": [
"p11:23"
],
"truth": "block should remain outside the accepted reference span",
"pipeline_behavior": "block appears inside the logical reference reading-order region",
"root_cause_hypothesis": "logical_order_between_reference_members",
"evidence": {
"annotated_page": "annotated_pages/page_011.png",
"artifact": "reference_span_audit.json"
}
},
{
"category": "reference_span_error",
"severity": "critical",
"block_ids": [
"p11:24"
],
"truth": "block should remain outside the accepted reference span",
"pipeline_behavior": "block appears inside the logical reference reading-order region",
"root_cause_hypothesis": "logical_order_between_reference_members",
"evidence": {
"annotated_page": "annotated_pages/page_011.png",
"artifact": "reference_span_audit.json"
}
},
{
"category": "reference_span_error",
"severity": "critical",
"block_ids": [
"p11:25"
],
"truth": "block should remain outside the accepted reference span",
"pipeline_behavior": "block appears inside the logical reference reading-order region",
"root_cause_hypothesis": "logical_order_between_reference_members",
"evidence": {
"annotated_page": "annotated_pages/page_011.png",
"artifact": "reference_span_audit.json"
}
},
{
"category": "reference_span_error",
"severity": "critical",
"block_ids": [
"p11:26"
],
"truth": "block should remain outside the accepted reference span",
"pipeline_behavior": "block appears inside the logical reference reading-order region",
"root_cause_hypothesis": "logical_order_between_reference_members",
"evidence": {
"annotated_page": "annotated_pages/page_011.png",
"artifact": "reference_span_audit.json"
}
},
{
"category": "reference_span_error",
"severity": "critical",
"block_ids": [
"p11:27"
],
"truth": "block should remain outside the accepted reference span",
"pipeline_behavior": "block appears inside the logical reference reading-order region",
"root_cause_hypothesis": "logical_order_between_reference_members",
"evidence": {
"annotated_page": "annotated_pages/page_011.png",
"artifact": "reference_span_audit.json"
}
},
{
"category": "reference_span_error",
"severity": "critical",
"block_ids": [
"p11:28"
],
"truth": "block should remain outside the accepted reference span",
"pipeline_behavior": "block appears inside the logical reference reading-order region",
"root_cause_hypothesis": "logical_order_between_reference_members",
"evidence": {
"annotated_page": "annotated_pages/page_011.png",
"artifact": "reference_span_audit.json"
}
},
{
"category": "reference_span_error",
"severity": "critical",
"block_ids": [
"p11:29"
],
"truth": "block should remain outside the accepted reference span",
"pipeline_behavior": "block appears inside the logical reference reading-order region",
"root_cause_hypothesis": "logical_order_between_reference_members",
"evidence": {
"annotated_page": "annotated_pages/page_011.png",
"artifact": "reference_span_audit.json"
}
},
{
"category": "reference_span_error",
"severity": "critical",
"block_ids": [
"p11:30"
],
"truth": "block should remain outside the accepted reference span",
"pipeline_behavior": "block appears inside the logical reference reading-order region",
"root_cause_hypothesis": "logical_order_between_reference_members",
"evidence": {
"annotated_page": "annotated_pages/page_011.png",
"artifact": "reference_span_audit.json"
}
},
{
"category": "reference_span_error",
"severity": "critical",
"block_ids": [
"p11:31"
],
"truth": "block should remain outside the accepted reference span",
"pipeline_behavior": "block appears inside the logical reference reading-order region",
"root_cause_hypothesis": "logical_order_between_reference_members",
"evidence": {
"annotated_page": "annotated_pages/page_011.png",
"artifact": "reference_span_audit.json"
}
},
{
"category": "reference_span_error",
"severity": "critical",
"block_ids": [
"p11:32"
],
"truth": "block should remain outside the accepted reference span",
"pipeline_behavior": "block appears inside the logical reference reading-order region",
"root_cause_hypothesis": "logical_order_between_reference_members",
"evidence": {
"annotated_page": "annotated_pages/page_011.png",
"artifact": "reference_span_audit.json"
}
},
{
"category": "reference_span_error",
"severity": "critical",
"block_ids": [
"p11:33"
],
"truth": "block should remain outside the accepted reference span",
"pipeline_behavior": "block appears inside the logical reference reading-order region",
"root_cause_hypothesis": "logical_order_between_reference_members",
"evidence": {
"annotated_page": "annotated_pages/page_011.png",
"artifact": "reference_span_audit.json"
}
},
{
"category": "reference_span_error",
"severity": "critical",
"block_ids": [
"p11:34"
],
"truth": "block should remain outside the accepted reference span",
"pipeline_behavior": "block appears inside the logical reference reading-order region",
"root_cause_hypothesis": "logical_order_between_reference_members",
"evidence": {
"annotated_page": "annotated_pages/page_011.png",
"artifact": "reference_span_audit.json"
}
},
{
"category": "reference_span_error",
"severity": "critical",
"block_ids": [
"p11:35"
],
"truth": "block should remain outside the accepted reference span",
"pipeline_behavior": "block appears inside the logical reference reading-order region",
"root_cause_hypothesis": "logical_order_between_reference_members",
"evidence": {
"annotated_page": "annotated_pages/page_011.png",
"artifact": "reference_span_audit.json"
}
},
{
"category": "reference_span_error",
"severity": "critical",
"block_ids": [
"p12:0"
],
"truth": "block should remain outside the accepted reference span",
"pipeline_behavior": "block appears inside the logical reference reading-order region",
"root_cause_hypothesis": "logical_order_between_reference_members",
"evidence": {
"annotated_page": "annotated_pages/page_012.png",
"artifact": "reference_span_audit.json"
}
},
{
"category": "same_page_boundary_error",
"severity": "major",
"block_ids": [],
"truth": "body/reference/backmatter boundaries should be explainable at block level",
"pipeline_behavior": "page contains mixed body/reference/tail signals",
"root_cause_hypothesis": "same-page boundary ambiguity",
"evidence": {
"annotated_page": "annotated_pages/page_011.png",
"artifact": "page_risk_summary.json"
}
},
{
"category": "render_mapping_error",
"severity": "minor",
"block_ids": [
"p1:0",
"p1:4",
"p1:12",
"p1:14",
"p1:15",
"p2:1",
"p2:2",
"p2:3",
"p2:9",
"p2:13",
"p3:0",
"p3:2",
"p3:10",
"p3:11",
"p4:1",
"p4:2",
"p4:5",
"p4:6",
"p5:0",
"p5:2"
],
"truth": "rendered fulltext should be traceable back to source blocks",
"pipeline_behavior": "some render-default blocks are not easily mapped into the current fulltext output",
"root_cause_hypothesis": "render omission or snippet mismatch",
"evidence": {
"annotated_page": null,
"artifact": "fulltext_block_mapping_summary.json"
}
}
]
}